Woman Refuses To Watch Sister Again After Family Claims She “Broke Her Leg”


Being accused of something you didn’t do is an awful feeling. It gets even worse if the thing you’re blamed for is particularly horrible, like hurting someone you love. And if your accuser is unwilling to even listen to your side of the story? Well, that’s bound to damage your relationship with them.


Redditor u/Electrical-Night-388 recently asked the ‘Dusty Thunder’ subreddit for advice about a sensitive subject. She wondered whether she was wrong to refuse to ever babysit her sister again, a year after her mother falsely blamed her for breaking the little one’s leg. Scroll down to read the full story and to see the internet’s take on things. Bored Panda has reached out to the author for comment, and we’ll update the article as soon as we hear back from her.


Babysitting is a very responsible job. Despite your best efforts, however, accidents can and do happen from time to time


Young woman watching a child jump on a trampoline outdoors, highlighting family conflict over a broken leg claim.


Image credits: Jayson Hinrichsen / Unsplash (not the actual photo)


A young woman shared how her mom falsely blamed her for hurting her sister the last time she babysat her


Text excerpt about a woman refusing to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg.


Woman refuses to watch sister again after family claims she broke her leg, showing frustration and family conflict setting.


Text excerpt from a woman refusing to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg, expressing frustration.


Text excerpt about a woman refusing to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg.


Young girl crying while woman holds her hands, depicting emotional distress related to woman refusing to watch sister again.


Image credits: Getty Images / Unsplash (not the actual photo)


Text excerpt describing a woman bouncing on the edge and falling, related to family claims of a broken leg incident.


Text snippet describing a woman refusing to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg, showing concern and panic.


Text excerpt describing a woman refusing to watch her sister after family claims she broke her leg, highlighting family conflict.


Text about a woman refusing to watch sister after family claims she broke her leg during a tense family dinner.


Woman sitting on bed wrapped in blanket, looking distressed and holding her forehead after family claims sister broke her leg.


Image credits: Valeriia Miller / Unsplash (not the actual photo)


Woman refuses to watch sister again after family falsely claims she broke her leg causing tension and worry.


Text excerpt showing a woman expressing regret and frustration about family claims and consequences after an incident involving a broken leg.


Text from a woman explaining why she refuses to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg.


Image credits: Electrical-Night-388


Two women having a serious conversation on a couch, reflecting tension related to family and broken leg claims.


Image credits: Nini FromParis / Unsplash (not the actual photo)


Clear and direct communication can be very powerful. If someone is trampling over your boundaries, you need to speak up


Communication is one of the most significant tools in your arsenal. We don’t want to sound cheesy, but being able to communicate your wants and needs clearly is one of the subtlest but most powerful superpowers anyone can have.


Another mundane but vital superpower is being able to enforce healthy boundaries with anyone. Starting with strangers and coworkers, and then even with family and friends.


The fact of the matter is that nobody is a mind reader (even if they sometimes feel like they are). So, if there’s something bothering you about a person’s attitude, you need to directly address the issue.


The odds are that the other person won’t magically be aware of your needs and feelings about something unless you spell it out to them. It’s also healthier to tackle the issue head-on (albeit in a semi-friendly way) instead of staying silent and letting things fester.


For example, if you’re uncomfortable with doing somebody favors, like babysitting, after a traumatic incident, then you need to let them know. Similarly, if somebody’s accusing you of horrible things, you need to stand your ground, speak up, defend your innocence, and let them know that what they’re doing won’t fly.


The other person has to be on the same page as you. They need to know what behavior you find unacceptable. They should also understand that if they continue ignoring your boundaries, there will be consequences.


For example, you could explain to them that if they keep blaming you for something awful that you never did, you’ll spend less time with them or stop doing favors for them entirely.


“Respectfully setting boundaries about your personal life can ensure a healthy family dynamic and teach you how to communicate your needs,” Charlie Health says, explaining why boundaries are so important.


“Setting boundaries with your parents is an opportunity to become more independent, own your values and beliefs, and establish guidelines on how you’d like to be treated by others.”


Young woman looking distressed outdoors, reflecting on family conflict involving sister and broken leg claims.


Image credits: BĀBI / Unsplash (not the actual photo)


Protecting your boundaries isn’t something to feel guilty about. You need to prioritize your well-being


What’s more, these clear boundaries can help you put your well-being first, avoid being co-dependent, and navigate conflict in a healthy way.


It’s vital to remember that you, as an individual, have the right to be treated with respect, prioritize your needs, make mistakes, not meet people’s unreasonable expectations, and say ‘yes’ or ‘no’ without feeling guilty.


According to Charlie Health, some unhealthy family dynamics, where better boundaries could be needed, include the following situations:



  • You feel responsible for your parents’ well-being and for fixing their problems;

  • Your parents feel entitled to know everything about your life or give out unsolicited advice;

  • You don’t know how to avoid conflict with your relatives;

  • Your parents are so influential that you find it hard to develop a sense of self;

  • Your parents guilt or shame you for the choices you make that give you more freedom.


If the situation is particularly tense, you can always reach out to someone you trust in your life, like a friend, colleague, relative, or other authority figure, for advice. What’s more, therapy can also be incredibly beneficial, whether you go see a licensed professional alone or with your parents.


What are your thoughts, dear Pandas? Do you think the author of the post was right to ignore her mother’s request to babysit her sister? What would you have done if you were in her shoes and were accused of hurting her sister? How do you maintain healthy boundaries with your family? Share your take in the comments.


Many readers were shocked that the young woman’s mom accused her of such a horrible thing


Screenshot of a user comment discussing family conflict after a woman refuses to watch her sister following a leg injury claim.


Text from a woman refusing to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg, emphasizing self-protection and boundaries.


Text conversation discussing a woman refusing to watch her sister after family claims she broke her leg during babysitting.


Reddit user explains refusing to watch sister after family falsely claims sister broke her leg in an online discussion.


Online discussion about woman refusing to watch sister again after family claims she broke her leg.


Screenshot of an online comment discussing a woman refusing to watch her sister after family claims she broke her leg.


Comment about a woman refusing to watch her sister after family accuses her of causing a leg injury.


Comment discussing family conflict and refusal to watch sister after claims of breaking her leg in an online forum.


Comment explaining a woman refuses to watch sister after family claims she broke her leg during a risky activity.


Screenshot of a forum comment discussing discomfort in watching sister after family claims she broke her leg.


Comment discussing dangers of pushing a story about a woman refusing to watch sister after alleged leg injury claim.


Comment discussing disbelief about family claiming a child broke her leg at a jumping place, urging not to trust her.


Screenshot of a Reddit comment discussing a woman refusing to watch sister after family claims she broke her leg.


Screenshot of a comment stating refusal to watch sister again after family’s claim she broke her leg.


Reddit comment expressing frustration about family drama and refusing to babysit after sister allegedly broke her leg.


Comment on a forum discussing a woman refusing to watch her sister after family claims she broke her leg, expressing safety concerns.


Comment discussing refusal to watch sister after family claims she broke her leg, expressing lack of trust and harm concerns.


Screenshot of a forum comment discussing a woman refusing to watch sister again after family claims she broke her leg.


Comment on a forum post reading about a woman refusing to watch her sister again after family claims she broke her leg.


Reddit comment urging refusal to babysit sister after family claims she broke her leg in an accident.


Some internet users felt inspired to share similar stories from their lives


Screenshot of a Reddit conversation about a woman refusing to watch her sister after family claims led to broken leg concerns.


Comment discussing false accusations and family conflicts after woman refuses to watch sister following broken leg claims.